Potluck potato salad recipe - easy and budget-friendly
"Please come to our potluck wedding," said our friends. "It's on Easter Sunday." Hmm. All right. My mission: find a suitable potluck dish that was...
- easy to make
- easy to double or triple
- easy to serve
- affordable
- possible to make & refrigerate the night before
- free of weird ingredients (we were asked to provide a list of ingredients for the safety of guests observing certain diets or avoiding certain allergens)
I was this close to making Bruce's grandmother's delicious potato salad, but it's seasoned with a Knorr product called Aromat, which is primarily salt, MSG, lactose, wheat starch, partially hydrogenated peanut oils... in short, an anaphylactic shock waiting to happen. So I opened up How to Cook Everything by Mark Bittman and used his "Classic American Potato Salad" recipe with a small tweak (the sour cream).
Here's what I did to serve 12.
- One five-pound bag red-skinned potatoes
- 1-1/2 cups minced fresh parsley (I used curly)
- 3/4 cup minced white onion
- 3/4 cup reduced-fat mayonnaise
- 3/4 cup lowfat sour cream
- Salt & freshly ground white pepper to taste
Bring a big pot of water to a boil. Salt it. Wash and scrub those potatoes (because who wants to peel five pounds of potatoes?), then cut into bite-sized pieces. Add potatoes to boiling water and cook them until tender but firm - not mushy - for 15 minutes. Drain, rinse in cold water, drain again.
Return the potatoes to whatever large vessel you have (say, that cooking pot), add parsley and onion, and toss. Add mayonnaise and sour cream and combine. Season with S&P, refrigerate until serving time.
Bittman says you can refrigerate it for up to a day before serving, but you want to bring it to room temperature to serve.
Pros: it's delicious, universally liked, easy to serve. Cons: you absolutely must take away and discard the leftovers, no sneaking "one more bite." After a couple of hours on a potluck buffet spread, nobody should eat anything with mayonnaise in it. But then, frankly, nothing that's sat out that long should go into your mouth, mayo or no mayo.
(Revoke my B.A. in English if you want to. But I'm leaving that misplaced modifier in the previous paragraph right where I wrote it. The image it conjures up makes me laugh.)